Best Dog Chew Toys

The goal with a heavy chewer is a toy hard enough to survive and soft enough not to fracture a tooth, and that rules out more products than most buyers expect. Natural rubber compounds formulated for power chewers flex under a molar and rebound, which is why they last months where a standard toy lasts an afternoon; rigid nylon and hard plastic bones do not flex at all and are the usual cause of slab fractures on the upper carnassial teeth. The genuinely useful safety feature to look for is a wear indicator, a differently coloured inner layer that becomes visible once the outer wall is chewed through, because it removes the guesswork about when a toy stops being safe. Size is not a matter of buying the biggest: a toy must be too large to pass the back of the throat but small enough to grip and carry, and one sized for a large breed frustrates a medium dog into ignoring it. Hollow designs that take paste or kibble extend the time a dog stays interested from minutes to something worth measuring, and they should be dishwasher safe or you will stop filling them. Inspect chews weekly and retire anything with a torn edge or a missing piece, whatever the marketing claims about being indestructible.

Sort byOur scoreValueBuild and materialsFeaturesFit for the jobTick up to 3 picks to compare them side by side.

Compare

#1

KONG Extreme Durable Natural Rubber Dog Toy for Power Chewers

Our score9.1/10

See on Amazon

KONG's Extreme durable natural rubber dog toy for power chewers, the black rubber classic for tough jaws.

Fit for the job 10/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 9/10

• + KONG Extreme black rubber is built for the strongest chewers
• + Hollow center can be stuffed with treats for longer play
• + Bone shape has four Goodie Gripper spots for stuffing treats

• - Pick a size bigger than your dog's mouth to avoid swallowing risk
• - Unpredictable bounces can knock things over indoors

Check price on AmazonSave

Compare

#2

KONG Extreme Dog Toy, Treat-Filling Natural Rubber for Power Chewers, Large

Our score9.1/10

See on Amazon

KONG's Extreme large treat-filling natural rubber dog toy for power chewers and bigger breeds.

Fit for the job 10/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 9/10

• + Large size suits big dogs and is safer against swallowing
• + Treat filling turns chewing into a long enrichment session
• + Natural rubber is durable and easy to rinse clean

• - Large toy is too big for small dogs to carry
• - Stuffed treats can make a mess on carpets

Check price on AmazonSave

Compare

#3

KONG Extreme Goodie Bone, Durable Natural Rubber Dog Bone, Medium

Our score8.6/10

See on Amazon

KONG's Extreme Goodie Bone in medium, a durable natural rubber bone with treat grooves for power chewers.

Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 8/10

• + Goodie grooves hold treats or paste for extended chewing
• + Medium bone shape suits mid-size dogs with strong jaws
• + Extreme rubber is tougher than KONG's standard red line

• - Treat grooves need cleaning to avoid sticky buildup
• - Medium size is too small for large breed chewers

Check price on AmazonSave

Compare

#4

Goughnuts Original Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers, Indestructible Ring, Green

Our score8.4/10

See on Amazon

Goughnuts' green Original ring for aggressive chewers, an indestructible style chew ring built for heavy use.

Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 7/10

• + Ring shape is easy for dogs to hold and gnaw
• + Goughnuts focuses on toys for the most destructive chewers
• + Green color shows clearly if the outer layer is chewed through

• - Pricier than typical rubber chew toys from mainstream brands
• - Heavy ring can hurt if dropped on toes or thrown indoors

Check price on AmazonSave

Compare

#5

Goughnuts Heavy Duty Dog Chew Ring for Large Breeds, Black

Our score8.4/10

See on Amazon

Goughnuts' black heavy duty chew ring for large breeds, a thick ring made for dogs who destroy other toys.

Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 7/10

• + Heavy duty design is aimed specifically at large breeds
• + Black color hides dirt and drool marks between washes
• + Thick ring gives large jaws plenty to chew on

• - Too big and heavy for small and medium dogs
• - Premium price compared with standard rubber rings

Check price on AmazonSave

Compare

#6

SIHRMIU 2 Pack Dog Chew Toys for Aggressive Chewers, Tough Indestructible Bones

Our score7.0/10

See on Amazon

SIHRMIU's 2 Pack of tough bone chew toys for aggressive chewers, sold as indestructible for strong jaws.

Fit for the job 7/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 6/10 · Value 8/10

• + 2 Pack lets you rotate bones to keep interest up
• + Tough bone shape is easy for dogs to grip and gnaw
• + Budget pack offers an affordable test for heavy chewers

• - Indestructible claims vary, so supervise powerful chewers
• - Lesser-known brand with little detail on the material

Check price on AmazonSave

Apartment Pet Picks independently selects every product; we may earn a commission from links above.